New flicks with celebs in interfaith relationships and from interfaith backgrounds, plus their baby news!Go To Pop Culture
Shaul Kelner, a Jewish studies professor at Vanderbilt University, takes Steven Cohen–and outreach advocates like ourselves, as well–down a notch with his wonderfully sensible op-ed for The Forward.
Essentially, he argues that debating over the value of outreach to the intermarried is misguided because in a pluralist Jewish world, there are spaces where outreach is promoted and there are spaces where it is shunned:
It’s a valid point, one made by author Anita Diamant in an interview we did with her for the 200th issue of our Web Magazine. She said opposition to intermarriage is a rearguard action. In Reform synagogues and even many, if not most, Conservative synagogues, intermarriage is an accepted part of life, and non-Jewish partners are an accepted part of the community.
Kelner also makes the good point that prophets of doom and gloom have been predicting the decline of the American Jewish community for years and it still hasn’t happened:
And, he could also note, that the Reform movement grew in numbers from 1990 to 2000, as demographer Len Saxe argues in his latest study.
The (New York) Jewish Week Editor Gary Rosenblatt plants another flag for pluralism in his latest column on people who ask to cancel their subscription. One of the most common reasons people cancel is Julie Wiener’s monthly column on intermarriage. “Just about every time ‘In the Mix,’ Julie’s column, appears, a few subscribers cancel,” he says.
But that doesn’t change his resolve to keep publishing the column, he says, because “the way we see it, we simply are recognizing that intermarriage is here to stay–affecting the majority of Jewish families indirectly if not directly–and that our job is to report on the community as it is, not just as we would like it to be.”
Note: All comments on InterfaithFamily are moderated. Any comment that is offensive or inappropriate will be removed.