We here at InterfaithFamily believe, like the rabbis of old, that language is extremely important. The rabbis of the Talmud wrote about the power of words. God created the world with words. God said, â€śLet there beâ€¦â€ť and there was. The rabbis said that to embarrass someone was akin to killing their soul (bringing blood to the face). They spoke against lashon harah (gossipâ€”literally the evil tongue). There are prayers about guarding our tongues from evil and our lips from deceit. The Amidah, the central prayer in the Jewish worship service, begins with a line asking God to open our lips that our mouth can declare Godâ€™s glory. The old adage, â€śsticks and stones can break our bones but words can never hurt usâ€ť is indeed not very Jewish. The words â€śthingâ€ť and â€śwordâ€ť in Hebrew share the same root â€śdâ€™varâ€ť teaching that our words create reality.
It is because words are so important that you may notice that we avoid using the term, â€śnon-Jewâ€ť because we donâ€™t promote the idea that someone can be a â€śnon-entity.â€ť We rather say, â€śsomeone not Jewish.â€ť You may feel that this is just semantics, but we disagree.
Many Jewish institutions ask people if they are affiliated with a congregation on membership forms and surveys. The Jewish world wants to know who is a member of a synagogue and what behaviors they have as opposed to people who are not members of a synagogue. We are also interested in tracking synagogue membership for dozens of other reasons (although the topic of another blog, I personally believe it is extremely difficult to raise children with Judaism without the help of a congregation or organized community whether school, community center or chavurah).
Here are my top five reasons for not using the word â€śunaffiliatedâ€ť anymore:
- This is an insider Jewish professional term that creates even more distance between the paid leaders and the people. Sometimes people do not know what it means to be â€śaffiliatedâ€ť and thus again on Jewish flyers and brochures are words and sentiments that donâ€™t ring a bell or resonate and can make people feel like outsiders.
- Affiliation is a euphemism (donâ€™t you love euphemisms?) meaning that someone pays synagogue dues. In rare cases, someone may feel so connected to a Jewish Community Center that they feel they â€śgoâ€ť there or â€śbelongâ€ť there but by and large this term is asking if someone is a member of a synagogue. If we want to know if someone goes to a synagogue, we should ask that and then explain why â€śweâ€ť want to know that.
- People may be affiliated with many different things that bring them closer to Judaism and this question, implying synagogue membership, is outdated, not nuanced and doesnâ€™t refer to the interesting places people go and what that brings them there. For instance, some people are affiliated with or connected to secular non-profits like food depositories, animal shelters, hospitals and educational programs. Volunteer work for these causes brings sacred purpose and is done in the name of tikkun olam (repairing our broken world).
- Some people have been turned off by synagogues and being asked over and over whether they are affiliated with a synagogue can feel like a reminder that they are outsiders, or even different from â€śgoodâ€ť Jews and that their disconnect is problematic. Maybe we should be asking people what synagogues could offer or feel like, and whether they would like to have clergy in their lives for counseling, life cycle events and learning opportunities. Itâ€™s not that people donâ€™t want this. They are not sure if they will find these things in synagogues.
- Jewish leaders have a goal of increasing affiliation rates. There are many reasons for this. Interfaith families connected to congregations typically have high levels of Jewish behavior like celebrating holidays, sending children to religious school, etc. Jewish leaders want to ensure that people are â€śdoing Jewishâ€ť because it is a civilization and a way of life worthy of living and passing on, and because we care about Jewish continuity. I think synagogues, in theory (and many in practice), are definitely the best vehicles for helping people live Jewishly and pass it on to the next generation. But because it is â€śpositiveâ€ť to be affiliated, it can be interpreted as â€śnegativeâ€ť to be unaffiliated, as though one is harming the Jewish people. Nobody wants to wear or own a negative label or have a finger pointed at them.
Language matters. Labels matter. This is how people end up feeling connected or disconnected. If we stop calling people â€śunaffiliatedâ€ť and start talking about who they are, what they are interested in or what would make them want to join or help create an organized Jewish community, we may find more answers.